What goes around comes around for an unremorseful widower, an arrogant fitness club owner and an unsuspecting thief. Meanwhile, Bobby gets a surprising phone call from his doctor after donating at Chimney's blood drive, and Athena confronts Michael after having a heart-to-heart with their kids.
- Angela Bassett as Athena Grant
- Peter Krause as Bobby Nash
- Oliver Stark as Evan Buckley
- Aisha Hinds as Henrietta Wilson
- Kenneth Choi as Howie Han
- Rockmond Dunbar as Michael Grant
- Connie Britton as Abigail Clark
- Tracie Thoms as Karen Wilson
- Corinne Massiah as May Grant
- Marcanthonee Jon Reis as Harry Grant
- Gavin Stenhouse as the Priest
- The bullet in the tree scene is an often told tale, about a jilted lover, jealous husband, and a dead wife. Is the tale true or not, it can't be told one way or another.